Fish Cake Recipe with Flaky Fish and Potato

This fish cake recipe is about as East Coast as it gets. You’ll spot fish cakes on menus all along the coast.

They show up on pub plates, served beside chow chow.

Sometimes they are the comforting “special.”

Sometimes, it feels like someone’s nan is running the kitchen.

And honestly? That’s the whole point. These are nostalgic, no-fuss, real-deal fish cakes that taste like home, even if you didn’t grow up eating them.

I’ve made versions of this fish cakes recipe for years. It takes me back to my roots— the kind of food I grew up with.

It’s a classic for a reason: simple ingredients, familiar flavours, and a method that’s easy to carry forward into your own kitchen. You’ll end up with crisp, golden brown edges, a soft middle, and enough herby brightness to keep every bite interesting.

And yes—we’re forming them into hockey puck shapes. Had to do it. Hockey is our sport.

At a Glance

• Classic East Coast Comfort: Crispy, flaky, and nostalgic
• Budget Friendly: Great use for simple pantry staples
• Perfect Weeknight Dinner: Easy and satisfying
• Meal Prep Friendly: Great leftovers the next day
• Golden Crispy Edges: Pan-fried perfection
• Family Approved: Comfort food everyone loves

Fish Cake Recipe: The East Coast Formula

At its core, a classic fish cake recipe is simple: cooked fish + mashed potato + seasoning, formed into patties, and cooked until crisp. That’s it. But the details matter—especially if you want that old-school diner texture (tender and fluffy, not gummy), and that “can’t stop eating this” flavour.

This recipe uses a mild white fish (I’m using haddock) and three russet potatoes mashed into about 2 cups. That potato-to-fish balance is where the magic lives: the potato gives structure so the cakes hold together, while the fish stays front and centre.

A quick note on the fish: 1 pound is plenty to make a solid batch of fish cakes that can work as a main dish or an appetizer (depending on how big you make them).

Picking The Fish For This Fish Cake Recipe

I’m using haddock because it’s classic East Coast, mild, and flakes beautifully. But you can absolutely make this with other mild white fish too—think cod, halibut, flounder, or alaskan pollock. The goal is a fish that’s not too oily, cooks gently, and flakes clean.

If you’ve got leftover fish from last night—poached, baked, or pan-cooked—this is a perfect way to turn it into something new. I love a kitchen “second act,” and this fish cake recipe is one of the best.

(And yes, I know salmon cakes are a thing. I love them too. But this is a different lane: classic East Coast fish patties, lighter and more delicate, with that potato comfort.)

The Potato Part: Why Russets Give You The Right Texture

Russet potatoes are the move here because they mash up fluffy and dry (in a good way). That drier mash helps your mixture hold together without needing extra binders or “mystery” additions. If your mash is too wet, you end up chasing it with more flour and losing that soft, tender interior we’re after.

One of my best tricks for this fish cake recipe: mash the potatoes, then let them steam off for a minute or two before you mix. It keeps the mixture from turning sticky.

Fish Cake Recipe: The Flavour Crew

This is where the fish cake recipe gets its personality.

You’ve got diced white onion and sliced leek—both sautéed—so they’re sweet and mellow, not sharp. Then we bring in fresh herbs: green onions, dill, lemon zest, and the superstar ingredient: summer savoury.

Summer savoury is pure Nova Scotia energy. It’s herby, a little peppery, and it gives these classic fish cakes that “oh yeah, that’s the one” flavour. If you’ve ever had savoury in stuffing or biscuits, you know what I mean—it tastes like East Coast kitchens and family dinners.

We keep seasoning straightforward: salt, black pepper, and optional Old Bay if you want that extra coastal kick. A little melted butter gives richness and helps everything come together.

If you love classic East Coast comfort food, you should absolutely check out this traditional Maritime Chow Chow recipe from Saltscapes. That sweet and tangy chow chow pairs beautifully with crispy homemade fish cakes and brings serious old-school Maritime vibes to the table.

Mix It Right

When you combine everything in a large bowl, you’re aiming for a mixture that holds together when you press it, but doesn’t feel like paste. Think: cohesive, flecked with green onions and herbs, and still fluffy.

This is also where I like to remind people: don’t overmix. A gentle fold keeps the potato light and the fish in flakes rather than mush.

Once it’s mixed, give it a short rest in the refrigerator. Even 15–20 minutes helps the mixture firm up so you can form patties without frustration.

Hockey Pucks, Small patties, and Everything In Between

My official shape recommendation: hockey puck-style fish cakes. Thick, sturdy, and satisfying.

But you can absolutely go smaller if you’re making them as an appetizer—think small patties you can serve with a dip and lemon. Either way, press them firmly so they don’t crack.

Pro move: place formed patties on a baking sheet in a single layer while you finish shaping. It keeps things neat and makes the breading step quick.

The Crispy Coat

We’re going full classic breading station here: flour, whisked eggs, then panko. That panko crunch is what takes these from “good” to “can I have one more?” If you see me writing panko breadcrumbs or panko breadcrumbs, I’m talking about the same thing: light, crisp crumbs that brown beautifully.

When you bread them, press gently so the crumbs stick without smashing the cake. This is also why chilling the patties helps—cold patties bread cleaner.

Fish Cake Recipe: Crispy Exterior

For the classic finish, pan-frying is the move. A skillet over medium heat, steady and controlled, gives you that crisp exterior without burning. Cook in batches so you don’t crowd the pan (crowding creates steam, and steam is the enemy of crisp).

You’re looking at about 3-4 minutes per side, until deeply golden brown and hot through. A spatula makes flipping easier—thin, flexible, and less likely to tear the cakes.

If you want to hold a batch while you cook the rest, park finished fish cakes on a baking sheet and keep them warm in the oven. That’s how you keep everything crisp for serving.

Serving Them Up

This is the most East Coast plate I can think of: fish cakes with chow chow on the side, fried eggs or a simple side salad. Honestly, it’s perfect.

A squeeze of fresh lemon does wonders here—serve with lemon wedges and let everyone add their own squeeze of lemon.

And if you’re feeling saucy, a quick homemade tartar sauce is unreal: mayonnaise, chopped dill, a little parsley, a touch of garlic, lemon, salt and pepper—stir and you’re done. (You don’t need to complicate it; this is still real-food cooking.)

For the salad, I keep it simple: greens + lemon + a drizzle of olive oil. That brightness balances the buttery, herby cakes perfectly.

FAQ: Fish Cake Recipe

What kind of fish works best for fish cakes?

White fish like cod, haddock, or pollock work beautifully because they’re flaky, mild, and hold together well.

Can I use leftover mashed potatoes?

Absolutely. Leftover mashed potatoes are actually one of the best ways to make fish cakes because they help bind everything together beautifully.

How do I keep fish cakes from falling apart?

Make sure the mixture is chilled if it feels too soft, and avoid flipping them too early while cooking.

Can fish cakes be frozen?

Yes! Freeze uncooked or cooked fish cakes in an airtight container for up to 2 months.

What goes well with fish cakes?

Chow chow, tartar sauce, coleslaw, roasted vegetables, salad, or baked beans are all fantastic pairings.

Can I bake fish cakes instead of frying them?

Yes. Bake at 425°F until golden brown, flipping halfway through for even crispiness.

Final Thoughts

This is a classic with a long history for a reason. It’s affordable, comforting, and genuinely delicious. Make a batch for dinner, serve them as a party appetizer, or stash remaining fish cakes in the fridge so tomorrow’s lunch feels like a win. Either way, you’ll have a fish cake recipe that brings a little East Coast nostalgia straight into your kitchen—no passport required.

Other Recipes You Will Love!

Spiced Fish Tacos with Mango Cabbage Slaw

Zesty Fish Burger

East Coast Beer Battered Fish